Compare Comdirect vs XTB

Online brokers compared for fees, trading platforms, safety and more. See how Comdirect stacks up against XTB!

Comdirect vs XTB
open account	Open account	Open account 82% of retail CFD accounts lose money
overall rating	4.3	4.6
overall pros	Extensive range of products and exchanges Great mobile platform Rock-solid background	Low forex fees Free and fast deposit and withdrawal Easy and fast account opening
overall cons	High fees Complicated account opening for non-German/Austrian residents Slow phone support and no live chat	High fees for stock CFDs Product portfolio limited mostly to CFDs and FX Limited fundamental data
fees	2.0 No withdrawal fee High trading fees High stock and ETF fees High forex fees	3.7 Low forex fees Free withdrawal for transfers above $100 High stock CFD fees
account opening	2.6 No minimum deposit Fully digital account opening for German/Austrian residents Slow Not fully digital Complicated account opening for non-German/Austrian residents	5.0 Fast Fully digital No minimum deposit
deposit and withdrawal	3.5 Free withdrawal No deposit fee Several account base currencies Credit/Debit card not available Slow withdrawal - over 3 days	4.5 Credit/Debit card available Free withdrawal No deposit fee Few minor account currencies accepted
web trading platform	4.4 User-friendly Clear fee report Two-step (safer) login No price alerts CFD trading is on a separate platform	4.4 User-friendly Clear fee report Good search function No two-step (safer) login
mobile trading platform	4.7 User-friendly Two-step (safer) login Price alerts Search function is a bit complicated	4.4 User-friendly Price alerts Modern design No two-step (safer) login
desktop trading platform	3.5 Good customizability (for charts, workspace) Two-step (safer) login Price alerts No clear fee report available Outdated design	4.4 User-friendly Clear fee report Good customizability (for charts, workspace) No two-step (safer) login
markets and products	5.0 Stock ETF Forex Fund Bond Options Futures CFD Crypto Warrants	2.8 Stock ETF Forex CFD Crypto Real stocks and ETFs (only for some European clients)
research	4.0 Good interactive chart Trading ideas Data on asset fundamentals News is only in German	4.1 Good interactive chart Quality news flow User-friendly Limited fundamental data
customer service	2.8 Relevant answers 24/7 support No live chat Slow phone support	4.4 Phone support Live chat Fast response time No 24/7 support
education	5.0 Demo account Trading platform tutorial Educational videos	5.0 Demo account Trading platform tutorial Educational videos
safety	High level of investor protection Banking background Listed on stock exchange	Listed on stock exchange Negative balance protection Some clients regulated by top-tier FCA Does not hold a banking license
recommended for	Investors and CFD traders speaking German and focusing on European securities	Forex and CFD traders looking for low fees and great deposit/withdrawal service

Save this comparison!

Sign up and we'll send you this comparison in email so you can dig deeper later.

First name

Email address

I acknowledge that my information will be used in accordance with the Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy

About

Discover

Follow us