Intro
CFD trading and CFDs as financial instruments are legal and heavily regulated in most countries, like the EU member states, UK and Australia, but also banned or restricted in others, notably the United States.
Regulation for CFD trading aims to protect investors and maintain fair trading practices.
Measures include leverage restrictions, disclosure of information, publication of risk warnings, investor protection, and market abuse prevention.
Contracts for Difference (CFDs) as a trading instrument have gained popularity in recent years, as they allow investors to speculate on the price movements of various financial assets. However, the legality and therefore availability of CFD trading varies across different jurisdictions. In some countries, such as the United Kingdom, CFDs are legal and regulated by the financial authorities, while in other countries, such as the United States, they are banned or restricted by regulation.
In this article, we explore the regulatory landscape of CFD trading and shed light on the various regulations and restrictions governing its use, citing several country examples.
What are CFDs?
Before diving into the legal aspects, let's briefly recap what CFDs are.
CFDs are financial products that allow traders to speculate on the price movements of underlying assets, such as stocks, commodities, and currencies, without actually owning them. By entering into such a contract, traders can profit from both rising and falling prices, making it a versatile financial instrument.
Note that CFDs are high risk investments, especially due to the ability to use leverage, therefore traders should first understand and then carefully consider the risks and benefits before investing. You should also make sure to use a reputable and regulated broker for CFD trading, to ensure that the investment is safe and legitimate.
To help you get started and save you hours of research, our experts have put together a list of the top reliable, regulated CFD brokers, check it out!
The development of CFD trading regulation
CFD trading was introduced in the early 1990s in London and its regulatory framework has evolved significantly over the past few decades. It was originally developed as a way for traders to benefit from price changes in various assets without actually owning them. This approach offered advantages not easily accessible for certain assets through traditional ownership, such as margin trading and shorting.
In the early stages, CFD trading operated with relatively few regulations, but as the market grew and retail investors started participating in CFD trading, concerns arose regarding investor protection and market stability.
This prompted regulatory authorities to step in and establish guidelines and frameworks to address key aspects of CFD trading. These regulations aim to promote investor protection and transparency within the industry, and minimize risks associated with CFD trading.
The specific regulations governing CFD trading differ across jurisdictions, but their aim is generally to protect investors and maintain fair trading practices.
Some examples of the implemented measures include:
- Leverage restrictions: Regulators recognized the potential risks associated with high leverage in CFD trading. As a result, many jurisdictions have imposed leverage limits to protect retail traders from excessive losses. Example: leverage caps of 20:1 for currency CFDs or 2:1 for crypto trading.
- Negative balance protection: This requirement for brokers provides an overall guaranteed limit on the losses retail clients can realize.
- Risk warnings and disclosure requirements: To ensure that traders are aware of the risks involved in CFD trading, regulators have mandated brokers to provide clear and comprehensive risk warnings and disclosure statements. This helps traders make informed decisions and understand the potential implications of trading CFDs.
- Investor protection measures: Regulatory authorities have introduced measures to protect investors' interests, such as segregated client accounts. This ensures that client funds are kept separate from the broker's operational funds, reducing the risk of losing or misusing client assets.
- Market abuse prevention: Regulators have also focused on preventing market abuse and manipulation in trading in general, including CFD trading. They have implemented surveillance mechanisms to monitor trading activities and detect any irregularities or potential misconduct.
Regulatory frameworks continue to evolve in response to changing market dynamics and emerging risks, so make sure you are up to date with the latest regulations in your country.
Examples for CFD regulation in some selected countries
The regulatory landscape for CFDs varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. It is legal in most of Europe, and other major markets such as Australia and Canada, but there are a few countries where the provision of CFD trading services is illegal, one of which is the United States.
Let's take a closer look at some specific examples for how CFD trading is regulated:
European Union (EU)
CFD trading is fully legal in the EU and is regulated in by the national competent authorities in each EU member state. However, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) as an EU regulatory body has a coordinating role in the process.
In 2018, ESMA adopted a temporary measure that included restrictions on the marketing, distribution or sale of CFDs to retail investors. Following the end of the temporary measures, national competent authorities in most EU member states implemented similar restrictions by adopting national regulations concerning CFDs, based on the measure adopted by ESMA in 2018.
The product intervention measures adopted by ESMA in 2018 concerning CFDs included:
-
leverage limits set between 30:1 and 2:1, depending on the underlying asset: 30:1 is for major currency pairs, and 2:1 for cryptocurrencies
-
mandated negative balance protection
-
measures to enhance investor safeguards, such as the margin close-out rule
-
a standardized risk warning
Read more about ESMA regulation on CFD trading.
United Kingdom (UK)
In the UK, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) oversees the entities providing CFD trading services. The FCA has implemented strict regulations to ensure fair trading practices, including:
-
leverage limits: maximum of 30:1 (major currency pairs) and 5:1 (stocks)
-
standardized risk warnings
-
margin close-out rule: customer positions are closed out when their funds fall to 50% of the margin needed to maintain their open positions on their CFD account.
-
measures to prevent market abuse
-
In addition, as of January 2021, the provision of crypto CFD trading services to retail investors is illegal in the UK.
Read more about CFD trading rules in the UK.
Australia
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) regulates the entities providing CFD trading services in Australia. ASIC requires CFD providers to meet specific licensing and disclosure requirements to protect investors' interests. Measures in place include:
-
leverage ratio limits ranging from 30:1 to 2:1
-
standardization of margin-close out rules
-
negative balance protection
-
prohibitions on offering or giving of certain inducements
Read more about CFD trading rules in Australia.
India
The situation in India is not as clear-cut as elsewhere. Providing CFD trading services to retail investors is not illegal per se in India but this market segment is largely unregulated. To date, neither the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI), the country’s financial markets regulator, nor the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the central bank, have put in place regulations pertaining to CFDs. As such, there are no India-regulated brokers for trading CFDs. Indian residents can trade CFDs by opening an account with a foreign broker that offers these products.
Read more about CFD trading rules in India.
Other countries
You can find more detailed examples for CFD trading in some additional jurisdictions by checking out our articles on the best CFD brokers in the following countries:
Why is CFD banned in the US?
As we mentioned above, there is one major market where CFDs are banned, and that is the United States. The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) restricts CFD trading because it is considered a form of over-the-counter (OTC) financial instrument that is not compliant with US securities laws. Therefore, US residents are generally prohibited from trading CFDs.
The ban aims to address concerns about leverage and protect investors from potential losses. While CFD trading is prohibited for US citizens, US brokers can offer CFDs to residents of other countries. US traders will also find that brokers regulated in offshore jurisdictions such as in the UK by the FCA will not permit US citizens to open CFD accounts.
Providing CFD trading services to retail investors is also illegal in some other jurisdictions, such as in Hong Kong.
Beware scam brokers
With the growing popularity of CFD trading, it is crucial to be aware of potential scams and unregulated brokers. There are many entities out there operating without proper licenses and trying to exploit unsuspecting traders.
At BrokerChooser, we are dedicated to helping our readers, and we are especially committed to saving them from running into scams and losing money to fraud. That is why we created our Scam Broker Shield tool, where you can easily check whether your broker is trusted by BrokerChooser. Simply enter the name of a broker and see if it can be trusted.
It is important to conduct thorough research, choose reputable brokers regulated by recognized authorities, and exercise caution when selecting a CFD provider.
Looking for the best CFD brokers?
Don’t want to spend hours upon hours researching to find the best CFD broker? No worries, you are in the right place!
Fortunately, our expert team has done all the work for you, and reviewed all the major brokers based on BrokerChooser's unique methodology.
As a result, we have compiled a list of brokers that offer the best CFD trading conditions overall: check our top recommendations of the best CFD brokers in the world available in your country.
