feed linkedin-square facebook-square twitter-square question-circle-o

Comdirect Alternatives

May 2019
Our top picks for Comdirect alternatives
Degiro
Saxo Bank
Comdirect Alternatives

The best alternatives to Comdirect are

  1. Degiro - Dutch discount broker
  2. Saxo Bank - Danish investment bank
  3. Flatex - Germany-based stockbroker

Let's see in a bit more detail how the Comdirect alternatives compare to Comdirect and each other:

Comdirect alternatives comparison
Comdirect Degiro Saxo Bank Flatex
Overall score 4.2 4.7 4.7 4.1
Fees score 2 stars 5 stars 3 stars 3 stars
Account opening score 2 stars 5 stars 3 stars 2 stars
Deposit and withdrawal score 4 stars 3 stars 5 stars 3 stars
Web platform score 4 stars 4 stars 5 stars 3 stars
Markets and products score 3 stars 3 stars 4 stars 3 stars
Visit broker Visit broker Visit broker Visit broker

Why are these brokers considered good alternatives to Comdirect? There are many areas based on which Comdirect can be compared with others. When we say a given online broker is a good alternative to Comdirect we mean these brokers are comparable in the following areas:

  • The products they offer, meaning you can buy mostly the same things, i.e. stocks, CFDs, options, etc.
  • The type of clients they target, i.e. beginners, experienced investors, or day traders.

Comdirect alternatives recommendations

Brokers are different in a number of ways, which means each of them may be suitable for different people. Here's how they compare overall:

  • Comdirect is recommended for german speaking investors and cfd traders focusing mainly on european securities
  • Degiro is recommended for price-sensitive buy and hold investors and traders looking for only execution
  • Saxo Bank is recommended for investors and traders looking for a great trading platform and solid research
  • Flatex is recommended for german speaking investors and cfd traders focusing mainly on european securities

Important factors of finding Comdirect alternatives

So far Brokerchooser has reviewed 57 online brokers in detail, which gives this comparison a solid starting point.

Not only that, but all of these brokers are reviewed using the exact same broker review methodology, which makes everything easily comparable. For each broker, we

  • open a live account
  • check over 100 criteria, with weighting based on readers' preferences
  • refresh data regularly

Whether Comdirect or one of its alternatives is the best choice for you is on the following five broker characteristics that most interest people:

Fees. There are different types of fees that your online brokerage may charge, and both the number and the size of these fees may vary significantly from broker to broker. Both of these aspects can impact your returns and your overall experience. Comdirect is considered to be a rather expensive broker. This gives you a good chance to cut your costs by choosing a cheaper Comdirect alternative.

Account opening. To open an account some brokers require at least €50,000 to be invested, while others don't set a minimum first-time deposit. The time it takes to open your account can be very different as well. At Comdirect, the account opening is slower than average, so if you consider this important some Comdirect alternatives can be a good choice.

Deposit/withdrawal. The number of ways that you can deposit or withdraw money to or from your account matters a lot. For example, while you cannot make a deposit with your credit card at Comdirect, some alternatives might allow you to do that.

Web trading platform. While online brokers are usually available on various platforms like mobile apps, tablet apps or desktop software, most people use them through their web platform in a browser. User-friendly trading platforms that offer many different resources can significantly increase your trading comfort.

Markets and products. A lot of people have specific products they would like to invest in. Knowing whether stocks, forex, mutual funds, and other products are available at the given Comdirect alternative is a must.


Now let's dive into the details of how Comdirect and its alternatives perform in the most important areas!

Comdirect alternatives
Comdirect

4.2 4 stars

Comdirect logo

Comdirect is a German online broker established in 1994. It is regulated by BaFin, the German financial authority. It is listed on the Xetra and London Stock Exchange. Its bank parent is Commerzbank.

Condirect is considered safe beacuse it is listed, regulated by a top-tier regulator and has a bank parent.

Recommended for german speaking investors and cfd traders focusing mainly on european securities

Pros
  • Great research tools
  • Trading platform is customizable
  • Listed on a stock exchange, strong parent company
Cons
  • High fees
  • Complicated account opening for non-Germans/non-Austrians
  • Service only in German

Visit broker

Fees 2 stars

Comdirect trading fees are high, while non-trading fees are average.
Pros
  • No withdrawal fee
  • Transparent fee structure
Cons
  • High trading fees
  • Inactivity fee
  • High financing rate
Comdirect alternatives trading fees
Comdirect Degiro Saxo Bank Flatex
Apple benchmark fee $29.6 $1.4 $20.0 $36.4
Vodafone benchmark fee $29.9 $5.2 $15.0 -
EURUSD benchmark fee $28.6 - $58.4 $28.9

Includes spreads, commissions and financing rate for opening a position, holding for a week, and closing.
Position sizes: $2k for stocks and $20k for FX

More Visit broker

Account opening 2 stars

Account opening is easy and fully digital for German and Austrian clients, but complicated and long for other citizens.
Pros
  • Fully digital account opening process for German and Austrian clients
Cons
  • Complicated account opening for non-German citizens
Comdirect alternatives minimum deposit and account open times
Comdirect Degiro Saxo Bank Flatex
Minimum deposit $0 $0 $725 $0
Time to open account >3 days 1 day 1-3 days >3 days

Learn more about Comdirect minimum deposit here.

More Visit broker

Deposit and withdrawal 4 stars

The deposit and withdrawal is free of charge, but you can it do it only via a bank transfer.
Pros
  • Free withdrawal
  • No deposit fee
Cons
  • Credit/Debit card not available
Comdirect and alternatives withdrawal options and fees
Comdirect Degiro Saxo Bank Flatex
Bank Transfer Yes Yes Yes Yes
Credit/Debit card No No No No
Electronic wallets No No No No
Withdrawal fee $0 $0 $0 $0

More Visit broker

Web trading platform 4 stars

Comdirect's web trading platform is easy-to-use and it well customizable. You can also use several order types. The platform can be slow and the price alert function is missing.
Pros
  • User-friendly
  • Good search function
  • Good customizability (for charts, workspace)
Cons
  • No price alerts
  • Slow
  • Separate platform for CFD trading
Comdirect - Web trading platform
Comdirect and alternatives trading platform scores
Comdirect Degiro Saxo Bank Flatex
Web platform score 4 stars 4 stars 5 stars 3 stars
Mobile platform score 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars 4 stars
Desktop platform score - - 5 stars 3 stars

Learn more about Comdirect's web trading platform in the detailed Comdirect review.

Visit broker

Markets and products 3 stars

At Comdirect you can trade with all asset classes. The market and product coverage is mid-range, but there are a lot of investment funds, one of the bests.
Comdirect and alternatives markets and products
Comdirect Degiro Saxo Bank Flatex
Stock Yes Yes Yes Yes
ETF Yes Yes Yes Yes
Forex Yes No Yes Yes
Fund Yes Yes No Yes
Bond Yes Yes Yes Yes
Options Yes Yes Yes No
Futures Yes Yes Yes No
CFD Yes Yes Yes Yes
Crypto Yes Yes Yes No

More Visit broker

Verdict

Comdirect is a German online broker established in 1994. Its parent company is Commerzbank, one of the biggest banks in Germany.

It is a good broker if you speak German.

It has great research functions, a good trading platform. Its financial stability and transparency is high thanks to its parent company and its stock exchange listing.

On the other hand, the full service is German and fees are high. Account opening is possible for non-Germans/non-Austrians, but it is very complicated.

There is a Demo account, so feel free to try it out.

Comdirect
Summary Comdirect is a German investment bank offering online banking and brokerage services.
Fees score 2 stars
Recommended for German speaking investors and CFD traders focusing mainly on European securities

More Visit broker

Comdirect alternatives
Degiro

4.7 5 stars

Best discount broker

Degiro logo

DEGIRO is a trending Dutch online discount broker. It is privately owned and was established in 2013 by former employees of another brokerage company.

DEGIRO is considered safe as it is regulated by top-tier financial regulators, the Dutch AFM and DNB. It is registered with the Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Amsterdam under number 34342820.

Recommended for price-sensitive buy and hold investors and traders looking for only execution

Pros
  • One of the lowest fees in the market
  • Broad access to international markets
  • Easy to use web and mobile platform
Cons
  • Limited research and education
  • No forex trading
  • No credit/debit card deposit and withdrawal

Visit broker

Fees 5 stars

DEGIRO has low trading and non-trading fees. In most asset classes, it is the best in the market. There are some ETFs which you can trade free once per month. It's a great offer for buy-and-hold investors.
Pros
  • Low trading fees
  • Low non-trading fees
  • No withdrawal fee
  • At some ETFs, one free trade per month
Cons
  • Yearly service fee for mutual funds
  • Higher trading fees for Asian and smaller European stock exchanges
Comdirect vs. Degiro: Trading fees
Degiro Comdirect
Apple benchmark fee $1.4 $29.6
Vodafone benchmark fee $5.2 $29.9
EURUSD benchmark fee - $28.6

Includes spreads, commissions and financing rate for opening a position, holding for a week, and closing.
Position sizes: $2k for stocks and $20k for FX

More Visit broker

Account opening 5 stars

DEGIRO has an easy and fast account opening process. Also, there is no minimum deposit.
Pros
  • Fully digital
  • No minimum deposit
  • User-friendly
Cons
None
Comdirect vs. Degiro: Minimum deposit, time to open an account
Degiro Comdirect
Minimum deposit $0 $0
Time to open account 1 day >3 days

If you are interested more in Degiro minimum deposit, this overview will help you.

More Visit broker

Deposit and withdrawal 3 stars

DEGIRO deposit and withdrawal is free of charge via bank transfer. On the other hand, you cannot deposit with credit or debit card.
Pros
  • Free withdrawal
  • No deposit fee
  • Several account base currencies
Cons
  • Credit/Debit card not available
Comdirect vs. Degiro: Withdrawal options
Degiro Comdirect
Bank Transfer Yes Yes
Credit/Debit card No No
Electronic wallets No No
Withdrawal fee $0 $0

More Visit broker

Web trading platform 4 stars

DEGIRO’s web platform is simple and easy to use. Even beginners can easily navigate it and buy stocks. On the negative side, it is a bit complicated to customize.
Pros
  • User-friendly
  • Two-step (safer) login
  • Modern design
Cons
  • Limited customizability (for charts, workspace)
  • No price alerts
Web trading platform of Degiro, a Comdirect alternative
Comdirect vs. Degiro: Trading platform scores
Degiro Comdirect
Web platform score 4 stars 4 stars
Mobile platform score 4 stars 3 stars
Desktop platform score - -

Learn more about Degiro's web trading platform in the detailed Degiro review.

Visit broker

Markets and products 3 stars

At DEGIRO you can access many markets and trade with a lot of different products, except for forex.
Comdirect vs. Degiro: Markets and products
Degiro Comdirect
Stock Yes Yes
ETF Yes Yes
Forex No Yes
Fund Yes Yes
Bond Yes Yes
Options Yes Yes
Futures Yes Yes
CFD Yes Yes
Crypto Yes Yes

More Visit broker

Verdict

DEGIRO is a good choice if you want a simple platform and don’t want to spend a fortune on fees.

It is far cheaper than its big European competitors and only Interactive Brokers can compete with DEGIRO fees. DEGIRO also has great access to international markets and trading products. And it is als one of the best trading platforms for Europeans.

However, cheapness comes with some shortfalls. Education and research tools are limited, there is no forex trading and limited deposit and withdrawal options.

All in all, it is a great online broker. As there is no minimum deposit and no inactivity fee, feel free to try it out.

Degiro
Summary DEGIRO is a Dutch discount broker established in 2008. It is regulated by the Dutch FMA.
Fees score 5 stars
Recommended for Price-sensitive buy and hold investors and traders looking for only execution

More Visit broker

Comdirect alternatives
Saxo Bank

4.7 5 stars

Best trading platform

Saxo Bank logo

Saxo Bank is a Danish investment bank providing online trading and investments. It is a leading European retail brokerage innovator. Saxo is privately owned, established in 1992, and headquartered in Copenhagen.

Saxo is considered safe as it is regulated worldwide by more than 10 financial regulators, including top-tier regulators, like the UK FCA.

Recommended for investors and traders looking for a great trading platform and solid research

Pros
  • Outstanding research
  • Great trading platform
  • Broad product portfolio
Cons
  • High forex, bond, options, and futures fees
  • Slow account opening
  • Missing live chat

Visit broker

Fees 3 stars

Saxo Bank has average trading and non-trading fees.
Pros
  • No withdrawal fee
  • Transparent fee structure
  • Lower fees for Platinum and VIP clients
Cons
  • Inactivity fee
  • High financing rate
  • High forex, bond, options and futures fees
Comdirect vs. Saxo Bank: Trading fees
Saxo Bank Comdirect
Apple benchmark fee $20.0 $29.6
Vodafone benchmark fee $15.0 $29.9
EURUSD benchmark fee $58.4 $28.6

Includes spreads, commissions and financing rate for opening a position, holding for a week, and closing.
Position sizes: $2k for stocks and $20k for FX

More Visit broker

Account opening 3 stars

Account opening is available for residents of almost every country and is fully digital.
Pros
  • Fast
  • Fully digital
  • Available for residents of almost every country
Cons
  • Minimum deposit is higher than $500
  • Sales team pushy
  • Classic accounts available only in a single currency
Comdirect vs. Saxo Bank: Minimum deposit, time to open an account
Saxo Bank Comdirect
Minimum deposit $725 $0
Time to open account 1-3 days >3 days

If you are interested more in Saxo Bank minimum deposit, this overview will help you.

More Visit broker

Deposit and withdrawal 5 stars

Saxo provides multiple deposit and withdrawal options free of charge on a user-friendly interface.
Pros
  • Free withdrawal
  • No deposit fee
  • Several account base currencies
Cons
  • Credit/Debit card withdrawal not available
Comdirect vs. Saxo Bank: Withdrawal options
Saxo Bank Comdirect
Bank Transfer Yes Yes
Credit/Debit card No No
Electronic wallets No No
Withdrawal fee $0 $0

More Visit broker

Web trading platform 5 stars

Saxo Bank's web trading platform is easy-to-use and well-designed. However, it doesn't provide a two-step login and the customizability is limited.
Pros
  • User-friendly
  • Good search function
  • Modern design
Cons
  • No two-step (safer) login
  • Limited customizability (for charts, workspace)
Web trading platform of Saxo Bank, a Comdirect alternative
Comdirect vs. Saxo Bank: Trading platform scores
Saxo Bank Comdirect
Web platform score 5 stars 4 stars
Mobile platform score 5 stars 3 stars
Desktop platform score 5 stars -

Learn more about Saxo Bank's web trading platform in the detailed Saxo Bank review.

Visit broker

Markets and products 4 stars

At Saxo Bank you can reach many markets and trade with a lot of different products, except for funds.
Comdirect vs. Saxo Bank: Markets and products
Saxo Bank Comdirect
Stock Yes Yes
ETF Yes Yes
Forex Yes Yes
Fund No Yes
Bond Yes Yes
Options Yes Yes
Futures Yes Yes
CFD Yes Yes
Crypto Yes Yes

More Visit broker

Verdict

Saxo Bank is a great broker, providing a complex and good service.

It has the best trading platforms backed by great research. The product portfolio is covering all important international markets and asset classes.

It has some drawbacks though. The fees for forex, bond, options, and futures are high. The account opening can take long and the live chat is missing.

In general, Saxo Bank is one of the best online brokerage companies you can choose. By opening an account, you end up with a broad, well-developed service.

Saxo Bank
Summary Saxo Bank is a Danish investment bank. It is regulated by more than 10 financial authorities, including the top-tier FCA.
Fees score 3 stars
Recommended for Investors and traders looking for a great trading platform and solid research

More Visit broker

Comdirect alternatives
Flatex

4.1 4 stars

Flatex logo

Flatex is a German stockbroker established in 1999 and regulated by the Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin). It is listed on the Xetra stock exchange and has a bank parent, the Fintech Group Bank AG.

Flatex is considered safe because it has a long track record, is listed on stock exchange, has a banking background, discloses its financials, and is regulated by top-tier regulator.

Recommended for german speaking investors and cfd traders focusing mainly on european securities

Pros
  • Cheap ETF and fund trading
  • Listed on a stock exchange, strong parent company
  • Great educational tools
Cons
  • Complicated account opening for non-Germans
  • Only bank transfer is available for deposit and withdrawal
  • Services are only in German

Visit broker

Fees 3 stars

Flatex has average trading fees and low non-trading fees.
Pros
  • No withdrawal fee
  • No inactivity fee
  • Low fund fees
Cons
  • High financing rate
  • High US stock fee
  • High forex fees
Comdirect vs. Flatex: Trading fees
Flatex Comdirect
Apple benchmark fee $36.4 $29.6
Vodafone benchmark fee - $29.9
EURUSD benchmark fee $28.9 $28.6

Includes spreads, commissions and financing rate for opening a position, holding for a week, and closing.
Position sizes: $2k for stocks and $20k for FX

More Visit broker

Account opening 2 stars

The account opening is easy and digital for German clients, but complicated and long for other citizens.
Pros
  • No minimum deposit
  • Fully digital account opening for German clients
Cons
  • Slow
  • Not fully digital
  • Not user-friendly
Comdirect vs. Flatex: Minimum deposit, time to open an account
Flatex Comdirect
Minimum deposit $0 $0
Time to open account >3 days >3 days

If you are interested more in Flatex minimum deposit, this overview will help you.

More Visit broker

Deposit and withdrawal 3 stars

Flatex offers free deposit and withdrawal. On the other hand, you can transfer money only by bank transfer and this takes a longer time.
Pros
  • Free withdrawal
  • No deposit fee
Cons
  • Credit/Debit card not available
  • Only one account base currency
  • Slow withdrawal - over 3 days
Comdirect vs. Flatex: Withdrawal options
Flatex Comdirect
Bank Transfer Yes Yes
Credit/Debit card No No
Electronic wallets No No
Withdrawal fee $0 $0

More Visit broker

Web trading platform 3 stars

Flatex web trading platform is user-friendly and looks nice. You can also use several order types. On the flip side, it is not customizable, there are no price alerts, and it is available only in German.
Pros
  • User-friendly
  • Good search function
  • Good variety of order types
Cons
  • Limited customizability (for charts, workspace)
  • No price alerts
  • Only in German
Web trading platform of Flatex, a Comdirect alternative
Comdirect vs. Flatex: Trading platform scores
Flatex Comdirect
Web platform score 3 stars 4 stars
Mobile platform score 4 stars 3 stars
Desktop platform score 3 stars -

Learn more about Flatex's web trading platform in the detailed Flatex review.

Visit broker

Markets and products 3 stars

Flatex gives you access to almost all asset classes, only options, futures, and cryptos are missing. Within the available asset classes, Flatex focuses mainly on EU markets.
Comdirect vs. Flatex: Markets and products
Flatex Comdirect
Stock Yes Yes
ETF Yes Yes
Forex Yes Yes
Fund Yes Yes
Bond Yes Yes
Options No Yes
Futures No Yes
CFD Yes Yes
Crypto No Yes

More Visit broker

Verdict

Flatex is a great broker if you speak German and you focus on long-term investing.

It has cheap ETF and fund trading and its financial transparency is great thanks to its bank parent company and its stock exchange listing. You can also use many high-quality educational tools.

On the other hand, the account opening for non-German citizens is very complicated and you can only use bank transfer for deposit and withdrawal. The account opening process, the web and mobile trading platforms and the telephone customer support are only in German.

Feel free to try Flatex, since there is no minimum deposit and inactivity fee.

Flatex
Summary Flatex is a German broker regulated by top-tier regulators, like the German BaFin.
Fees score 3 stars
Recommended for German speaking investors and CFD traders focusing mainly on European securities

More Visit broker

Comdirect alternatives
Bottom line

Based on our analysis, there are several good alternatives to Comdirect. They all offer similar products and target similar customers. Here's a recap of the results in a table.

Comdirect alternatives
Broker Info Recommended for
Comdirect German investment bank German speaking investors and CFD traders focusing mainly on European securities
Degiro Dutch discount broker Price-sensitive buy and hold investors and traders looking for only execution
Saxo Bank Danish investment bank Investors and traders looking for a great trading platform and solid research
Flatex Germany-based stockbroker German speaking investors and CFD traders focusing mainly on European securities

Still unsure? Use our broker finder and find the best broker for you or learn more about investing your money.

AUTHOR

Dan Sallai
Dan Sallai
CMO
My goal is to help people find our resourceful content when they need the most. I combine my 10+ years online marketing experience with the team's finance knowledge to reach that every day. On the side I'm paying bowling, tennis and enjoy spending great time with my children.
Follow Brokerchooser on Twitter

Share

Comments